Dirty Wars and Democracy

When the past informs the present…

Ex-Soldiers Want to Reveal Chile Dirty War Secrets

Posted by svolk on 1st November 2009

In Chile, “moment has come” for ex-soldiers to reveal secrets of Pinochet dictatorship

By EVA VERGARA, The Associated Press

SANTIAGO, Chile

Hundreds of former military draftees rallying outside Chile’s presidential palace were asked Sunday to come forward and reveal crimes they committed and witnessed during Gen. Augusto Pinochet’s dictatorship.

The draftees have long feared that if they name names and reveal where bodies are buried, they will face prosecution by the courts or retaliation by those who ordered them to torture and kill.

But now the information they once promised to carry to their graves has become both a heavy psychological burden and a bargaining chip. By offering confessions, some of these now-aging men believe they can improve their chances of getting government pensions and mental health care.

“Perhaps today is the day when the moment has come, for us to describe what we saw and what we suffered inside the military bases, the things that we witnessed and that we did,” said Fernando Mellado, who leads the Santiago chapter of the Former Soldiers of 1973.

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in: , , , , | No Comments »

Argentina: las mujeres siguen desapareciendo

Posted by svolk on 30th December 2008

Upside Down World, Maria Luisa Peralta, Dec. 30, 2008

Diciembre es un mes especial en Argentina. El 10 de diciembre de 1983 asumió un presidente elegido por voto popular, dando fin a la última dictadura militar y marcando el inicio de la recuperación democrática. Este mes, se cumplieron 25 años de ese día y abundaron los balances. Muchas cosas están pendientes para poder hablar de democracia real, y numerosos análisis hicieron hincapié en la “calidad institucional” y en la pobreza extendida que alcanza grados de miseria en amplias zonas del país (hay unas 25 muertes diarias de niñas y niños vinculadas al hambre). Pero pocos fuera del movimiento de mujeres resaltaron la persistencia de un fenómeno que obedece ahora a causas distintas que las que tuvo durante la dictadura pero cuyo peso simbólico debería ser insoportable: la desaparición forzada de personas.

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in: , , | No Comments »

Thousands of Human Bone Pieces Found in Argentine Jail

Posted by svolk on 10th December 2008

BUENOS AIRES (AP) — Inside a once secret detention center where political dissidents were tortured and killed during Argentina’s dictatorship 25 years ago, forensic anthropologists have discovered a pit containing 10,000 bone fragments.

The discovery, the first of human remains in a detention center, supports the testimony of hundreds of survivors who have said for years that the authorities tortured and killed political opponents and burned their bodies.

“This scientifically confirms the testimonies of the detained,” said Luis Fondebrider, a forensic anthropologist who helped uncover the remains in the former detention center in La Plata known as Arana.

The bone fragments were unearthed between February and September, and Mr. Fondebrider and his team announced Tuesday that the remains were human. Now, months of laboratory work is needed to determine even the minimum number of bodies that were destroyed in the pit.

But the evidence already shows that bodies were thrown into the pit, covered with fuel and burned along with tires, to mask the smell of burning flesh. More than 200 bullet marks were found along an adjacent wall.

The bones were not completely reduced to ash, allowing for genetic analysis to identify the dead. But Mr. Fondebrider cautioned that it would not be possible to identify many of the victims, because prolonged exposure to fire destroys most DNA.

“This is the first time there is proof that Arana wasn’t only a detention and torture center, but also a center of elimination,” said Marta Vedio, legal chairwoman for the Permanent Assembly for Human Rights La Plata.

Some backers of the military dictatorship have denied that detainees were tortured or killed, despite the well-documented toll from the so-called dirty war, a crackdown in which political opponents of the junta disappeared with their spouses, children and other innocent people whose names were in their address books.

Official records put the number who disappeared at 13,000. Human rights groups say 30,000 were killed.

New York Times – Dec. 10, 2008

Posted in: , , , | No Comments »

A Tortuous Path To Spain’s Painful Past

Posted by sfaber on 24th November 2008

Crusading Judge’s Exit From Probe Of Civil War-Era Mass
Graves May Leave Truth In The Ground
By Christine Spolar
Chicago Tribune November 19, 2008

PINILLA DE LA VALDERIA, Spain-Many people in this
verdant countryside know their hills and valleys hide a
terrible treasure from the Spanish Civil War: Skeletons
of loved ones, just a few generations gone. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in: , , , | No Comments »

Manifiestos de apoyo a Garzón

Posted by sfaber on 20th November 2008

El País, 20 de noviembre de 2008

Unos 30 intelectuales artistas y familiares de la víctimas del franquismo han presentado hoy en Madrid un manifiesto de apoyo al juez Garzón. El documento, con el título ‘Hemos conocido’ cuenta con el respaldo del premio Nobel de Literatura José Saramago, el escritor argentino Ernesto Sábato, el historiador Ian Gibson o el cantautor Paco Ibánez, quien ha presentado el manifiesto junto a Cristina Almeida en el círculo de Bellas Artes

A partir de ahora el texto podrá firmarse. Sus promotores quieren entregarlo con el mayor número de apoyos al Gobierno el próximo 14 de abril, día en que se conmemora la proclamación de la Segunda República. .

Durante la presentación del manifiesto, el presidente de la Asociación para la Recuperación de la Memoria Histórica, Emilio Silva, ha denunciado que el fiscal de la Audiencia Nacional que se opuso a que el juez Garzón instruyera el caso de las fosas ha hecho “injusticia” con una mano y “política” con la otra.

El representante de la asociación ha afirmado que lo que ha hecho Garzón es una “inhibición activa”, gracias a la cual “da a conocer los hechos” sucedidos bajo la dictadura franquista “tal como fueron”.

Además, un grupo de unos 40 juristas suscribe hoy otro manifiesto de Amnistía Internacional con el título ‘Para pasar página primero hay que leerla’ en el que se denuncia que la justicia española haya investigado crímenes contra la humanidad en varios países y se hayan abstenido de hacerlo en su propio Estado.

Posted in: , , , , | No Comments »

Spanish Judge Drops Probe Into Franco Atrocities

Posted by sfaber on 19th November 2008

New York Times, November 19, 2008

By VICTORIA BURNETT

MADRID — A high-profile judge on Tuesday dropped a sensitive inquiry into atrocities that took place during the era of Franco, Spain’s former dictator, ending what had promised to be the first criminal investigation of wrongs committed by Franco and his allies.

The judge, Baltasar Garzón, last month declared himself competent to investigate the killings of 114,000 people at the hands of Franco’s supporters during the 1936-1939 civil war and the dictatorship that followed and ordered the exhumation of at least 19 mass graves. He accused Franco and 34 former generals and ministers of crimes against humanity.

However, Judge Garzón said Tuesday that he was dropping the case against Franco and his allies after state prosecutors questioned his jurisdiction over crimes committed 70 years ago by people who are now dead and whose crimes were covered by an amnesty passed in 1977. In a 152-page statement, he passed responsibility to regional courts for opening 19 mass graves believed to hold the remains of hundreds of victims, including those of Federico García Lorca, the Spanish poet. Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in: , , , , | No Comments »

No es la sociedad civil. Es el Estado

Posted by sfaber on 17th November 2008

30 países revisan su pasado más trágico y dejan en evidencia la escasa implicación del Gobierno español – Asociaciones de familiares han desenterrado ya 4.000 víctimas de la Guerra Civil

NATALIA JUNQUERA El País 17/11/2008

[...]

Políticas de memoria y reparación a las víctimas

- Argentina. Anuló las leyes de Obediencia Debida y Punto final (similares a una amnistía), juzgó y condenó a los represores y convirtió el símbolo del terror practicado por las juntas militares durante la dictadura (1976-1983), la ESMA, en un Museo de la Memoria.

– Chile. Las primeras excavaciones de fosas comunes comienzan durante la dictadura de Pinochet (1973-1990), lideradas por la Iglesia. Familiares de más de 3.000 ejecutados y de casi 30.000 torturados reciben pensiones económicas y servicios gratuitos. La presidenta del país fue víctima.

– Guatemala. El estado corre con los gastos de las exhumaciones en cementerios clandestinos e indemniza a las víctimas. Cuenta con el apoyo de la iglesia.

- Marruecos. El Rey Mohamed VI creó una comisión de la verdad para investigar las desapariciones, detenciones, torturas, violaciones y ejecuciones cometidas entre 1956-1999. Pidió perdón a las víctimas y se comprometió a hacer cambios en su Constitución para evitar que lo ocurrido se volviera a repetir.

– Suráfrica. Reconoció los terribles crímenes en audiencias públicas. No juzgó a los culpables. Estableció medidas de compensación económica para las víctimas difíciles de cumplir en el contexto de pobreza que vive el país.

- Alemania.Las potencias vencedoras de la Segunda Guerra mundial ya habían destruido los símbolos nazis. La cuestión más controvertida era el derecho. En 1998, el Parlamento aprobó una ley que anulaba las sentencias dictadas por el Tribunal Popular o en juicios militares sumarísimos.

Full article below the fold Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in: , , , , | No Comments »

Garzón strikes back

Posted by sfaber on 16th October 2008

[This from the BBC. See also the the New York Times.]

Spanish judge to probe Franco era

A Spanish judge has launched a criminal investigation into the fate of tens of thousands of people who vanished during the civil war and Franco dictatorship.

Judge Baltasar Garzon – Spain’s top investigating judge – has also ordered several mass graves to be opened.

One is believed to contain the remains of the poet Federico Garcia Lorca, who was murdered by fascist forces at the start of the war in the 1930s.

Correspondents say the historic ruling will be controversial in Spain.

They say there has been a tacit agreement among political parties not to delve too deeply into the civil war and Franco era.

In his 68-page ruling, Judge Garzon says that Francoists carried out “illegal permanent detentions” which he says falls within the definition of crimes against humanity.

Read the rest of this entry »

Posted in: , , | No Comments »

“Dos años sin el primer desaparecido de la democracia argentina”

Posted by svolk on 18th September 2008

Post from Maya Shulman-Ment

La Nacion (Buenos Aires), 18 septiembre 2008

El segundo aniversario de la desaparición de Julio López, el testigo clave del juicio que terminó con la condena a prisión perpetua al represor Miguel Etchecolatz, y de quien nada se sabe desde el 18 de septiembre de 2006 aparece reflejado hoy en la prensa española.

Bajo el título “Dos años sin el primer desaparecido de la democracia argentina”, el diario El País, en su edición internacional, asegura que la falta de avances en la investigación sobre su paradero implica que “el lema Nunca Más ha quedado incumplido”.

Tras relatar el secuestro y desaparición de López durante la última dictadura, el matutino reproduce las palabras del albañil ante el tribunal que juzgó a Etchecolatz, ex jefe de Investigaciones de la policía bonaerense.

Argentina disappeared

Palabras de López. “´Soy detenido en mi casa, va el señor Miguel Etchecolatz y se establece en un auto. A la noche llegó toda la patota, primero nos agarran y nos tiran a todos en la celda juntos´”, recuerda el diario.

Enseguida, consigna que López “iba a ser testigo en otros juicios contra 62 militares y policías, pero volvió a desaparecer” y incluye el testimonio de Rubén uno de los hijos de López que le dijo al diario español: “Sigo a buscando a mi viejo con vida”.

El artículo también repasa las declaraciones públicas acerca del caso de las últimas semanas. Reproduce los dichos de León Arslanian, ministro de Seguridad bonaerense cuando se produjo la desaparición, en los que reconoció que cree que López está muerto y los del juez de la causa, Arnaldo Corazza, quien también admitió que la muerte es una de las hipótesis que maneja en la investigación.

Por último, da cuenta del último discurso de Néstor Kirchner, en el que el ex presidente afirmó que la desaparición de López “demuestra que hay muchos que siguen organizados para que no haya justicia en la Argentina”.

Hipótesis y marchas. La nota, acompañada por dos imágenes, una de López durante el juicio contra Etchecolatz, y otra de una de las tantas manifestaciones frente al Congreso para reclamar su aparición con vida, consigna una de las hipótesis que se barajan en torno al caso: que con la desaparición de el albañil “se intentó amedrentar a otros testigos a otros testigos de los juicios contra la dictadura”.

Hacia el final, el texto informa que hoy habrá marchas en la Capital, en La Plata y hasta en la placa de Jacinto Benavente de Madrid.

Posted in: , , | No Comments »

Looking for the Disappeared in Colombia

Posted by svolk on 8th September 2008

The following story from NPR was just brought to my attention:

All Things Considered, September 5, 2008 · Colombia has been in the news lately for the success its U.S.-backed army has had against Marxist guerrillas. But there is an overlooked story in Colombia’s conflict — the story of how death squads killed thousands of people over many years and then buried the bodies in unmarked graves. They are the “disappeared.”

Teams of forensics anthropologists are now using shovels and pick axes to find them — and unearthing a dark chapter in a shadowy war.

Wilton Hernandez leads a government exhumation team of detectives, forensics experts and topographers that descended on a hamlet in Anori, northwest Colombia, recently.

“Many people until now have not even reported the disappearance of loved ones,” Hernandez says. “They remain alive in the census.”

Bringing Justice To Families

Colombia’s war continues, but special investigations have been launched to unearth the past and bring justice to thousands of families who lost relatives.

Under a three-year-old process aimed at dismantling the right-wing paramilitary structure, fighters have put down their weapons and are trying to rejoin civilian life. Former commanders are testifying about paramilitary activities — how they killed civilians to weaken their enemies, Marxist rebels.

Investigators are using that information and interviewing the relatives of the dead to find victims’ remains.

Mario Iguaran, the chief prosecutor in Colombia, says that evidence shows that there are more than 10,000 people buried in unmarked graves across Colombia, “disappeared,” he says.

The number is astonishing — three times what human rights groups estimated three years ago when the digging first began. That is more than the number of disappeared in Chile, Peru and El Salvador, where the tactic of disappearing adversaries was ingrained in state policy.

Finding The ‘Disappeared’

The town of Anori is so isolated it would take a couple of days to travel by mule to reach it. Instead, the exhumation team travels by helicopter, arriving in two Vietnam-era Hueys.

Upon landing, the lead investigator, Hernandez, uses a loudspeaker to tell villagers his team of forensics experts is about to head to the cemetery to start looking for victims. In minutes, half the town is following them to the dig.

Many paramilitary victims were hurriedly buried by relatives — their deaths never reported.

Two members of a team hammered away at a cement crypt. They pull out the remains of a body, the clothes still hanging off the bones. After tagging the bones, they bag the remains.

The remains will be taken back to the regional capital of Medellin to be registered and positively identified. That gives prosecutors hard evidence to be used against perpetrators. The bodies are eventually turned over to relatives for burial.

Paramilitary fighters beheaded Orlando Echevarria’s 19-year-old son Alonso, but Echevarria never reported the crime. He was afraid paramilitaries would return and harm others in his family.

“I feel better now,” Echevarria says. “I feel so much better than when I buried him. Now I’m happy.”

Finally making his death official was a big relief. For the exhumation team, it was another victory — another body to add to the 1,500 already unearthed since 2005.

But the challenges ahead are daunting.

Hernandez says that many remains are in unmarked graves or were thrown into rivers, never to be found again — no matter how much and other investigators try.

Posted in: , , | No Comments »